How to Negotiate When You're Underpaid
By AJ Mizes, Founder & CEO of The Human Reach · Updated 2026-06-25
If your pay drifted below market while you stayed loyal, raises tracked inflation instead of your growing value, and a new hire now earns more than you for the same work, you don't have a one-time ask. You have a gap to close, and closing it takes a different play than a standard raise conversation. Here's how I coach clients through it.
Confirm the gap is real before you open your mouth
Underpaid is a claim, and your manager will treat it like one until you prove it. Pull three sources: current job postings for your exact title and level in your metro, salary data filtered by location and years of experience, and any signal you can gather on internal bands or what recent hires command. Triangulate them into a defensible range, not a single number. If the market midpoint for your role is $135K and you're at $108K, that 20 percent gap is your headline figure.
Then separate the two questions that always get tangled. One is whether your pay matches the market for your role. The other is whether your level matches the work you actually do. People who feel underpaid are often also under-leveled, doing senior work at a mid title. Those need different fixes, and naming the right one keeps the conversation from sliding into a vague complaint.
Build the case on present value, not back pay
The instinct is to argue the history: I've been underpaid for three years, so you owe me. That framing loses. No manager has budget to refund the past, and it casts you as aggrieved rather than valuable. Reframe to the present. The question is what someone delivering your current scope is worth today, and the answer is a number your company would pay to hire that person right now. You're asking them to pay market for what they already have.
Assemble the proof the same way you'd build a promotion case. Document the scope you own now versus what you were hired for, the results with figures attached, the responsibilities you absorbed when others left, and the projects where you were the reason it shipped. The gap between your impact and your paycheck is your argument. I walk clients through structuring exactly this in Career Amp.
Ask for the full correction, in writing, with a timeline
A large gap rarely closes in one move, and you should plan for that without surrendering the full number. Open with the corrected figure backed by your market data: "Based on what this role pays in our market and the scope I'm carrying, I'm asking to move to $135K." Say it plainly and stop talking. Silence after the number is leverage, not awkwardness.
If the budget genuinely can't span it now, negotiate a written path rather than a vague "we'll revisit." That means a specific interim raise effective on a date, the remaining amount tied to a named review with criteria you both agree on, and a calendar commitment. Get it in an email you send summarizing the conversation. A promise that isn't dated and documented is a promise that evaporates at the next reorg.
Know your real alternative before you decide how hard to push
Your leverage in any pay conversation is what happens if they say no, so be honest with yourself about it before you walk in. The cleanest way to reset underpriced pay is often an external offer, because the outside market sets your value without your tenure dragging it down. You don't have to leave to use this. You do have to be genuinely willing to.
If you bring an outside offer, use it straight: "I'd rather stay, and here's what it would take." Don't bluff a number you can't produce, and don't issue a threat. Counteroffers can also reset the clock on resentment without fixing the underlying band, so weigh whether staying actually solves the problem or just delays the same conversation a year out. When clients are weighing stay-versus-go, that's the work I do with them at The Human Reach.
Handle the no without burning the relationship
If you get a flat no, your next sentence matters more than your disappointment. Ask what would have to be true for the answer to change, and get the criteria concrete: a specific scope, a metric, a title change, a date. That turns a dead end into a roadmap, and it tells you fast whether this is a budget problem or a you-problem in their eyes. A manager who can't name a single path to your number is telling you the ceiling is real.
Stay warm and stay employed-quality in your work, but start running a quiet external search in parallel. The strongest position is wanting to stay while being fully ready to leave. That calm shows up in the room, and it's usually what finally moves the number.
Frequently asked questions
Should I mention that a new hire makes more than me?+
Use it as private motivation to gather data, not as your argument in the room. Pointing at a coworker's pay reads as a fairness complaint and can violate confidentiality norms; instead, let it inform your market research and make your case about your own scope and market value.
How much of a raise can I realistically ask for to fix a big gap?+
Ask for the full market-corrected number, even if it's 15 to 25 percent above your current pay, as long as your data supports it. Anchor high and defensible, then negotiate the timeline if the budget can't absorb it all at once rather than pre-discounting your own ask.
What if my company says raises are capped at a fixed percentage?+
Standard merit caps are designed for cost-of-living bumps, not market corrections, so name yours as an equity or market adjustment, which most companies fund from a separate process. If that path is truly closed, a title or level change is often the only internal way to break the cap.
Keep reading
Want this done with you, not just read about?
AJ and The Human Reach coach professionals through exactly this. Career Amp is the flagship program.
Work With The Human Reach